Stila Alloy Waterproof Eyeliner Swatch - Stila Stay All Day Eye Liner Review

Finding your ideal eyeliner is akin to kissing a lot of frogs before finally discovering the prince. Every girl knows the story - an eyeliner may be too dark, too light, too waxy, too difficult to apply, dries too fast, or dries too slow.  With so many eye liner products on the market, it takes some time to uncover what best works for you.
I’ve been searching for a grey eyeliner that was a true grey without being too dark or too light. Because I don’t like sporting raccoon eyes half way through the work day, I also wanted a waterproof eyeliner that would stay put but would also be easy to remove (what can I say, I have high standards).
Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Eyeliner in the Alloy shade met all my requirements and more.  Stila Alloy is a beautiful medium true grey shade that brings out the eyes without being too harsh for every day wear.  I love the longevity of the Stay All Day collection as well - the product really does stay all day without smudging but easily wipes off at night (see what I there?). The only issue with this product is that the felt tip applicator may be a bit stiff at the beginning but after the first few uses, it becomes easier to maneuver.
Overall, precise application is extremely easy, and the liner color and shape can be intensified and layered.  Stila Waterproof eyeliners work on every type of eye lid and are guaranteed to stay on - my eyes are sensitive to the ingredients in some liners, but Alloy performed very well.  The whole collection has a beautiful range of shades so if you still haven’t found your “prince” eyeliner, head to your nearest Sephora to swatch the Stila All Day waterproof eye liners.
Stay Pretty, Miranda M.
  • Celina

    I have had my eyes on this eyeliner for a while now but I’m still working my way through a couple of existing eyeliners. This is definitely on my shopping list! xx
    Celina | The Celution | Bloglovin’

    • Pretty Squared

      I tried so many to find this one haha (and I have to go through mine too) but I really recommend this, it’s great quality and stays on for when it needs to.

  • vicki bruce

    Stay al day is music to my ears. I have really oily eyelids & so many eyeliners transfer on me or start going patchy throughout the day. This Stila one sounds great

    • Pretty Squared

      it works on oily lids too, I have the same issue and can use the liner without a primer at all - and it doesn’t smudge or get patchy either (give it a try, I was surprised more bloggers don’t talk about it, it’s awesome!).